Robert Archerd
2 min readJan 17, 2025

Dave, I thought for sure that you were going somewhere else, that you were going to mention the AA slogans that I find don’t hold up. They include the likes of, “Hi. I'm Bill. And I'm an alcoholic,” and, "It's one day at a time," and, "If you take one drink, you've fallen off the wagon,” to name just some that come readily to mind.

My dad, a two-fisted, whisky-drinking alcoholic and occasional stumbling drunk, belonged to AA and fully supported their rhetoric. When I was in my early 20s, and he'd been off whisky for years, I was aghast to see him sit with a friend and have a cocktail.

Uh-oh, I thought, he's fallen off the wagon! OMG!

But to my amazement, his life remained normal. I noticed that he could take an occasional drink and be fine. So, what’s with that?

Years later, I also began to drink. A little, at first. Then more. And finally, every evening until I was often shitfaced. My drinks of choice were rum, scotch, and vodka. Yes, I’d become an alcoholic!

But after more than 20 years of that, and in failing health, I stopped cold turkey.

All of that is now well in my past. And I’m the healthiest I’ve ever been. And I now look back at those AA adages with horror. If I were to say, “Hi. I’m Bob. I’m an alcoholic,” it would be total bullshit. I mean, how am I now an alcoholic? I have occasional drinks with no adverse effects. I drink a small glass of wine once or twice a week with my dinner.

And maybe once a year, or less, I’ll have one drink of hard liquor when out with friends. With no lingering cravings or adverse effects of any kind. And I haven’t had a hangover in more than 30 years.

So, the only purpose I can see for such lines as “I’m an alcoholic” or “It’s one day at a time” is to make sure that someone with a drinking problem remains a prisoner to that belief and under the control of AA’s leaders.

So, fuck that! I’m not an alcoholic. Yes, I was. In my now-distant past. But I am now a perfectly healthy 85-year-old who keeps himself in excellent physical and mental condition.

And the only way I’ll die any time soon is for someone to come along and beat me to death.

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

Robert Archerd
Robert Archerd

Written by Robert Archerd

Retired math/science educator, specialty in cognitive & moral development. Author of math & science programs , taught K thru grad level university.

No responses yet

Write a response